We visit Alexandria Bay about five to ten times per year and we, after trying many other hotels, have settled on Otter Creek Inn. The rooms are nicely furnished and spotlessly clean, and the prices are very reasonable. It is an easy walk to downtown ABay, and my grandson and I go fishing right from the docks at the hotel.... More

My 11-year-old grandson and I spent 2 nights in October, for our "guys' weekend out". We could not have found a better place to stay. The building is quite new, and everything was in excellent condition. Price is a fraction of the big-name places, yet it's walking distance to the heart of Alex Bay. Denis and Deb, the owners, were... More

I just got back from a great trip in Alex Bay. This was my third time to stay at the Otter Creek Inn and I appreciate it more every time I go. The location is perfect. It is just far away enough to not hear the bars and restaurants, but close enough to walk everywhere. There are comfortable chairs by... More

I have been visiting A-bay since I was a teenager. I formerly patronized the Fisherman's Wharf hotel back when I was a boat owner, before that property gave way to a failed condo project. We found a suitable replacement in the Otter Creek Inn. I would recommend it to all. Good value, friendly staff, and most amazingly a housekeeping staff... More

We always return to the Otter Creek Inn, the owners run an adult establishment. No loud parties or heavy drinking. The rooms and grounds are spotless. The rates are very reasonable, can't believe anyone would not love their stay here. More

There were many family and friends who went to the ocktoberfest in Alexandria Bay. Together we must have rented a dozen rooms here. I could not believe the way we were badgered by the owners! We were policed by the management like we were 16 year olds! A few people stayed at other motels but came to visit us. Upon... More

My wife and I stayed here for our one year anniversary, and we were very satisfied! It is a leisurely 5 minute walk to the main strip in Alexandria Bay, and is tucked away at the end of a nearby street, so it offers plenty of privacy. Plus, it has a small waterfront with several docks, in case you are... More

Just returned from a wonderful, first time trip to the Bay. We researched all the motels in the area before making reservations. Otter Creek had the best reviews and less expensive than any others. We weren't disappointed! We had a room with a king size bed on the first level. Being a nurse presently and many years ago I use... More

The Otter Creek Inn is a wonderful place to stay. It is a clean ,quiet , family oriented atmosphere. The owners are on site and are very helpful and friendly. The rates are very reasonable and boat dockage is available right at the Inn. We have thru the years stayed at other places in Alexandria bay but none of them... More