After at least 5 vacations at Old Finimore Mill, my husband and I almost didn't go this year. We were concerned about the bad reviews Old Finimore received on this site. We thought perhaps it had changed management and/or become run-down. It was quite the opposite. Our condo (2A) was beautifully furnished, well equipped with linens, towels, kitchen essentials, etc.... More

Lovely area on Cedar Key, but definitely not a 'luxury' resort as advertised on website. We found all the towels still in the dryer from previous guests and the dishes were still in the dish washer! We were told the swimming pool was heated, and I even asked before I booked the reservation. Upon arrival the manager informed us that... More

I was really looking forward to visiting Cedar Key. It is a small island with limited accommodations, but Old Fenimore Mill was disappointing to say the least. We stayed in Unit 1D. They have a futon for a sofa. It was extremely dirty and the throw pillows had all of these holes in them. Carpets in bedrooms were filthy. Ceiling... More

We recently spent a week in a lovely condo, Serenity, in building 7. It looked out on the shallows & was a constant source of beauty. I'm surprised my husband left the balcony at all, he was so enamoured of all the birds that stopped by for a meal! It was comfortable & convenient; we hope to return next year. More

This was old Florida at its best. Our one bedroom condo was right on the gulf and very well equipped. We could walk to everything and even had a few meals in the condo. It had everything. I highly recommend it. More

I will repeat this again: The view from Unit 9F is the best in Cedar Key. Today is our last day of vacation. Sadly, we have to leave tomorrow. Our accomodations have been some of the best we've ever stayed in, in Unit 9F at Old Finimore Mill Condos. Spouse and I have literally become addicted to the view, from... More

My wife and I were the other couple in 6C. We stayed with my Sister and her Husband for a week in late May and everything she wrote in her review about how dirty the place was is true! We arrived first and as soon as we walked through the door my wife was upset about how dirty the unit... More

We stayed at Old Fenimore Mill on the recommendation of some friends. This is not a bells and whistles resort if that is what you're looking for, but our room was very clean and tastefully decorated and it had a cold AC and comfortable beds. I would have liked a few more notes on where spare towels were (took us... More

This is by far the filthiest place I have ever stayed. We were told that the owners had 4 large dogs, but incorrectly assumed that the unit would be cleaned before we arrived. There is no way anyone even touched this unit after the onwers leashed their 4 dogs and vacated. Dog hair swirled in the air when we turned... More