Last year we visited Cedar Key and The Old Fenimore Mill Condo and liked it so much we made a slightly longer repeat visit this past March. We were welcomed and then left to our own devices. If we had questions helpful answers were given. Be warned there are no movie houses, the food market borders on minimal, however, it's... More

Have stayed in a lot of places along the gulf coast, but Cedar Key is special. We've been very pleased with two units at Fenimir Mills. This year we stayed in 2 D. The kitchen is really well equipped, with good numbers of glasswear, dishes, etc. Master bed is comfy. The unit even has a wine cooler, which we really... More

We stayed in unit 1C which was 2 BR 2 BA. We had a lovely view of the gulf from the balcony. Very spacious and nicely furnished (king bed, 2 twin beds, living room with large flat screen, dining table, kitchen appliances, washer/dryer). Walking distance to Dock Street. The only negative thing was that the code they gave us for... More

We have just returned from a month's visit to Old Fenimore Mill Condos. I had some reservations on reading the reviews but our experience at other hotels/ resorts has shown us to take the happy medium. I am SO glad we did. From the beginning, Bob, in the office,was so helpful suggesting condos to look at online and advising us... More

We rented 10B as we were in town for the seafood festival. It faces the back bayou and not the bay but you can see many birds as the tide ebbs. The unit was clean but not luxury as advertised by any means. The sheet on the bed was torn in places. The TV was fuzzy and not a flat... More

Great place to be even if a storm blows in because of your views of the Gulf and back bays. Many beautiful birds to watch. We rented from the on-site real estate manager. They were friendly and helpful. Our unit (and many others) are dog friendly. Lots of places to walk your dog. Walking distance to the restaurants and public... More

After at least 5 vacations at Old Finimore Mill, my husband and I almost didn't go this year. We were concerned about the bad reviews Old Finimore received on this site. We thought perhaps it had changed management and/or become run-down. It was quite the opposite. Our condo (2A) was beautifully furnished, well equipped with linens, towels, kitchen essentials, etc.... More

Lovely area on Cedar Key, but definitely not a 'luxury' resort as advertised on website. We found all the towels still in the dryer from previous guests and the dishes were still in the dish washer! We were told the swimming pool was heated, and I even asked before I booked the reservation. Upon arrival the manager informed us that... More

I was really looking forward to visiting Cedar Key. It is a small island with limited accommodations, but Old Fenimore Mill was disappointing to say the least. We stayed in Unit 1D. They have a futon for a sofa. It was extremely dirty and the throw pillows had all of these holes in them. Carpets in bedrooms were filthy. Ceiling... More