I stayed for one night with my husband and I'm glad we didn't stay longer. The hotel location was great - right on Duval Street within walking distance to everything. I guess I didn't expect it to be as loud as it was though. Yes, bar noise and bad musicians are to be expected, but motorcycle gangs driving down the... More

Great hotel. Very clean, luxurious showers in the bathroom. Comfy bed, big TV. Nice pool and bar. Best thing though: LOCATION! You can walk anywhere! Right on Duval, perfect location. Just a block up from the Green Parrot bar. More

My husband and I stayed at this hotel for three nights and it was great!!! It is right on corner of Duval street. The staff were very helpful and gave us suggestions on restaurants in the area!! They also recommended Sunset Watersports for parasailing and Sunset cruise which were both great fun!!! I would defintely stay at the Pegasus again!!!... More

Second time to Key West and again staying at this great hotel. Flew in on Cape Air and Marco from the Pegasus Hotel was waiting for us to bring to their hotel. Checked in by Swetlana who was very nice and knowledgeable about the area. Room was clean and very comfortable. This hotel is right in the middle of Duval... More

A terrific hotel right on Duval Street. Good amenities and a good price. More

My wife and I went for our third anniversary and we had a fantastic time. The staff was very friendly and had great suggestions for our stay. I think we have found the place for our fourth anniversary. More

I've been to kw multiple times and the location of this hotel is perfection! you can walk anywhere from there. Also the rooms were very clean and private which is nice when you are ready to sleep. The rooftop pool/sundeck is soooo nice for laying out and people watching on duval street. Nice having a free breakfast if you can... More

We read all the reviews and arrived a little concerned. We got exactly what we paid for, clean rooms at a good price right on Duval St. The hotel is located in the center of Duval St about 2 blocks from the bars so it is very quiet. Just be prepared for what it is and is not. It’s a... More

Stayed here for the first time with our friends and we are SUPER happy we did! It is in the middle of EVERYTHING. Yes, this is a boutique hotel but it is very well maintained, VERY clean and the staff is extremely friendly and accommodating. This will definitely be our go-to hotel each time we go to Key West. More