Perfect location and wonderful views, but...for the price, nothing complimentary offered, overpriced brunch, no soap in ladies lobby restroom, front desk did not call as promised when room was ready, NO ELEVATOR (3rd floor room UGH!!!), needs extensive renovations in Mayhew building. Beautiful grounds.

Booked into this hotel for four nights and in general an excellent stay, however - check in chap totally non friendly, we shouldn't want to check in at all, we have inconvenienced him - no hot water on the first morning, called the front desk, told by grumpy receptionist that hotel has problems with the pipes. No further explanation. Cold... More

We stayed in room 211 from May 30 to June 4. We have the following observations: 1. The front desk staff and the concierge staff are polite, pleasant, friendly and eager to please. I give them high marks. The bellmen were also very good. 2. The restaurant has a great view but is staffed by college kids not professional waiters... More

The Harbor View Hotel's location is outstanding. The views from the wrap-around porch of the lighthouse and Edgartown harbor were just fantastic. It is just a short walk into town for shopping and other restaurants. The grounds were impecible and the staff was very friendly and helpful. They have a Concierge service that will help you with any sightseeing trips... More

We stayed at the Harbor View and hope we can go back again next year. The service was outstanding - the staff is attentive and helpful. The site was magnificent -- poolside or on the porch -- not a bad seat in the house. Try the lobster roll by the pool!

Enjoyable weekend on the Vineyard with a young family member. Stayed in the Mayhew Building overlooking the pool area. It was nicely appointed although the hallways could use a makeover. Our room was comfortable with two double beds. Nicer quality bed linens and towels/toiletries.The bathroom could be updated some, a bit on the lower chain motel end. Overall we'd a... More

We picked this hotel for its beautiful location after cycling past it on a previous trip to the Vineyard. But the hotel has so much more to offer than an absolutely excellent location (which alone might already have been enough). The building itself and the rooms are charming and ooze history but the rooms are very 21st century with spacious... More

The property is nice and in the perfect location. Beautiful grounds and view of the lighthouse. Very short walk to the shops and restaurants. Love that they have the pet friendly rooms. Made it very convenient for us to bring our little yorkie with. The grounds staff was working very hard to get everything ready for the summer. Only complaints... More

The Harbor View is simply fantastic. We stayed with another couple in one of the two bedroom suites. The building had been beautifully renovated recently. The bedrooms were spacious and outfitted with luxurious linens as well as a very convenient hospitality station (e.g. counter area with refrigerator/freezer drawers, etc) The marble bathrooms were elegant with high end fixtures, towels and... More