My best friend and I really enjoyed our 2-night stay at The Blue Inn. We were here right before the start of the season and had the place almost entirely to ourselves. Our room was in the building in the back and had a very nice interior, was very clean and quiet. We enjoyed the little kitchen in our room... More

At first I thought this would be a positive experience because initially they seemed very accomodating boy we were in for a rude awakening, I will further explain. . My Birthday was going to be on Sept 22 2012. My boyfriend and I thought it would be nice to get away to the North Fork of Long Island for a... More

Very disappointing. The back is a motel and not an inn. The restaurant is mediocre at best - only crowded because it's fairly inexpensive for the area. Same with the inn- mediocre at best although I agree with the others that the front desk was very helpful. Rooms are clean - bathrooms are small - really small. Great location.

We stayed at here for a quickly planned get-away on Columbus Day weekend. The Inn part is attached the main office and appears to only be a few rooms. We had an upstairs room in the motel type building in the back. The room was clean and very pleasant. The bathroom was a little small compared to other places that... More

Take a close look at the website before booking. Most rooms are not in the inn but in the motel-like area in back. The rooms are appointed well but very small and face the parking lot or an empty lot to the side. Our room was not cleaned daily. The front desk staff and handyman were the highlights: helpful, accommodating... More

We stayed at the blue inn a few weeks ago in the back building that looks like a roadside motel. The rooms are okay, nothing special. We did have a number of flies and bugs, but I'm not sure if that is their fault. Last time we stayed at the Morning Glory Inn, which is amazing but more expensive. My... More

We had lived on the North Fork for a number of years and knew where not to stay, but the choices are limited.We reviewed trip advisor before our visit and hoped for the best when making reservations based on reviews and the knowledge that it had been renovated in recent years. This is not a large 5 star hotel, but... More

First impressions of the Blue Inn underwhelmed: the website (and price tag) had given the impression that it was more of a hotel but the bit we were in looks and feels like a motel; the office was closed when we arrived at 7:30pm and no one was answering the phone; and when we were finally directed to a room... More

On labor day weekend, it seemed like everyone was requiring a three night min, but the Blue Inn did not. We took a chance and stayed upstairs in the hotel-like section in the back. It was clean and comfortable. I always like having a little kitchen area, which was nice. The smell of lavender from next door was lovely! We... More