I have stayed there numerous times and I love the beds. The mattresses are the BEST and the sheets are crisp, clean and smell amazing. There are so many details to this guesthouse that always make me feel welcome...hairdryers, good boottles water, wonderful bath amenities filuffy towels and robes! It is SPARKLING CLEAN. I love that. We've satyed in some... More

This property is lovely. The rooms are spacious, clean, and decorated beautifully. The inn keepers are gracious and do a wonderful job as hosts from morning breakfast of Chobani Yogurt and granola cereal to afternoon cookie and wine. My husband and I highly recommend for a stay 2 minutes from downtown Hamilton. Reasonably priced.

For sure, the accommodations at the Weathervane are the best in town, and have the highest finish level (although I've not seen the rooms at the Colgate Inn since they've been renovated). But..you will pay a HEFTY price for a room with a high level of finish. Personally, I would only stay there if a) nothing else nice was available... More

Yes, this place is pricey. However, you get a super comfortable place to stay in Hamilton, NY that is also very quiet, since it is not right in the center of town. It is an easy drive to get anywhere in Hamilton from the guest house. Breakfast is not served, so this is just a place to stay over. The... More

I have stayed here several times and have shelled out the bucks because of the inn's location and amenities. I found this last trip, that the rates are still staggering high but breakfast is no longer included. Just not worth it. I could stay at the Four Seasons. The owners are taking advantage of Colgate parents who want to stay... More