We recently visited Colgate University and stayed at the Colgate Inn. What a charming hotel. I would highly suggest staying here if you can get a room since it is the only hotel in town and has only 40 rooms. The room was nicely furnished and comfortable. The bathroom was on the small size but that did not bother us.... More

We stayed here while visiting Colgate University. The Inn is charming with a nice restaurant/tavern on the first floor. Rooms are clean and location is perfect for the town. The staff is friendly and helpful. The only complaint is if you want to watch TV the bed post obstruct the view of the TV screen. Not sure why this was... More

This historic old hotel is located in the heart of the little town of Hamilton. The hotel is well run, clean and picturesque, but it has the downsides of a country inn: no room service and thin walls. Being the only real hotel for miles, all 40 rooms were fully booked on the rainy cold Wednesday night in April that... More

Very charming and comfortable hotel, right in the middle of Hamilton (which itself is charming too). Spacious and nicely-appointed rooms, free wifi, comfortable beds. Great breakfast available in the cafe/restaurant/bar downstairs.

If you're visiting Hamilton, NY or Colgate University and have a lot of spare pocket change you might enjoy the Colgate Inn. It's owned by the University and the room rates are exorbitant. There's no in room coffee and the restaurant is very expensive for beverage and food, but tasty. It was recently renovated, reducing the number of rooms by... More

Stayed here while traveling on business and it's my second visit. A New England Style Inn but really elegant like a stately home that's been passed from generation to generation. Warm inviting restaurant with a fire burning hearth. Nice dinner and great service. Beautiful central staircase with an amazing chandelier made entirely of branches....hard to explain but if you visit... More

We came to visit Colgate University, my son's first choice for college. We had come from staying at The Lord Jeffrey inn in Amherst, which also had been recently renovated. We were enchanted by the Colgate inn. The renovation was impeccable, the service warm, and the rooms spacious, luxurious, and charming. It is a splendid place, and if our son... More

My company held our annual Christmas party at the inn this year. We had a cocktail hour followed by dinner. The food was great and the service was even better. We supplied rooms for all our guests as there was drinking involved. Everyone has given super feedback on the Inn itself and the food. A great place to have a... More

This is the only game in town if you are looking to stay someplace with character. Decor is lovely. Rooms are comfortable but on the smallish side. Lighting is terrible in the rooms. They are very poorly lit. And there is a fair amount of noise between rooms and the corridor. However, it beats all other options nearby so reserve... More