I'm glad my wife looked up the reviews at this place last weekend when we were up in the Ithaca area. The food was fantastic and the atmosphere was warm and inviting with an eclectic feeling. I loved the micro brews they have. I would come back here again, too bad its a 4 hour drive from home. More

My husband and I travelled to Ithica for a long weekend getaway and had a wonderful experience. We really enjoyed Rogues Harbor Inn. Our room was so comfortable and very spacious! Each morning we had a delicious breakfast and I've got to say the fresh pressed coffee is incredible!! The entire staff was extremely nice and very accomodating. We went... More

Here is a breakdown: Excellent food in the restaurant Great micro-brewed beer Proprietor was not the warm-and-friendly hostess one would expect at a BnB, seemed uptight, not happy to accommodate Service was adequate Room was clean Bed was as comfortable as a concrete slab; couldn't relax, and we were in pain both mornings Due to the age of the building,... More

Stayed at the Rogue's Harbor Inn for my sister's 30th birthday for 2 nights with them and another couple. The Inn itself is nice and close to Ithaca, without having to deal with the hub-bub of downtown. The road the Inn is situated on is at the intersection of 2 roads, so at times you can hear the sounds of... More

The inn is at the intersection of 2 busy roads--we heard trucks downshifting all night. The decor in our room (#6) was drab and sad. Our beds were made up every day, but no clean towels were given and the floors were not vacuumed. The breakfasts were adequate. The staff was nice, but did not go out of their way... More

The hotel is actually in South Lansing, about 5 miles north of Ithaca. It is not really near anything else; if you were planning on wandering around you will have to do it by car. The hotel is historically interesting and has been restored modestly, not lavishly. If you are into high-end B&Bs, you'll probably be disappointed; if you're into... More

We managed to get a room here at a very crowded time in Ithaca NY--just before Cornell's graduation. The hotel has been lovingly restored but still shows its age by the distinctiveness of rooms. Ours was very comfortable with private bath. A breakfast was included. It also has a decent restaurant/bar on the ground floor--a real plus for a place... More

We stayed at the Inn during our son's wedding weekend. It is a lovely place - very quaint and definately better than a hotel/motel. The rooms are clean and the food is great. Off the beaten path a bit and that makes it all the better. Definately a place to visit again. More

I thought the place looked cute online and there were good reviews. This was the worst vacation ever. The bar and restaurant are fine, but the third floor seems like the building is sinking, all the floors and doorways are unsettlingly uneven. The place is so scary I couldn't sleep. It didn't help that there is horrible road noise and... More