This is my second time visiting Fire Island. This time I chose to stay on the island for 2 nights. I researched The Blue Waters and noticed the mixed reviews. I must say that for the price we were offered for 2nights and 3 days it was great! We payed a total of $400 and everything was included. -Breakfast -Bikes,... More

My adult daughter and I stayed one night, mid week. I was thrilled that they would let us stay just one night, rather than having a 2-3 night minimum. The room was very clean and comfortable. The fee included bikes (shiny and new), beach chairs (super comfortable back-pack style) and umbrella (also new) and towels. It was so nice to... More

For one weekend each of the past two summers, my friends and I have stayed in the Bay House Apartments, which are owned and managed by the same people as Blue Waters Hotel. (You check in at the hotel when you stay in the apartments.) The accommodations are great - spacious, clean, convenient location. However, the staff is another story.... More

Before coming to Ocean Beach, with which I am very familiar, I looked into all my options for a weekend stay and after finding the Blue Waters Hotel to be the most reasonable, I was shocked because it was nothing short of perfect for the beach. Fire Island really isn't the place to go on vacation if you're looking to... More

This is going to be a two part review. The hotel: Extremely basic. It makes a super 8 seem luxurious in comparison. I had the pleasure of staying in a nice hotel in NYC the night before for the same price and excellent location, and let me tell you, this place has only the basics--towels, bed, 15 channels, and hand... More

Uncomfortable beds, looks like a school or an office building. Rushed us out and tried to charge me an extra $50 for checking out a couple minutes late. Extremely rude and unprofessional, we will never be coming back. Located right next to the dock with very low rates, yet still no one stays there....now we know why. Stay away.

my wife and i stayed at the the blue waters hotel last week and just thought i had to write a review because we had such a great experience! i loved that they gave us chairs for the beach and bikes to use to explore the island. the rooms were very clean and the staff was very nice and accommodating.... More

My boyfriend and I just recently stayed at the Blue Waters Hotel. We received warm service by the girls behind the desk and a very clean, cozy room. The room was perfect for a 2-night stay at the beach. The hotel gives out beach chairs, towels and beach bikes which was great! We had a very pleasant experience at this... More

The experience was nothing short of wonderful.The staff treated us like we were the only ones staying there. They answered all of our questions and made the whole experience worth coming from nj. I would highly recommend everyone staying at the Blue Waters as the staff is extrmeely helpful and knowledgeable of the island. As far as the rates go,... More