We went out of the city for a short break and found this little hotel. It was not exactly how pictured it to be. The room was wonderful full of amenities. Beachfront view. Loved the sun deck. Not much of a beach but it was quiet. Dinner is not bad. Decent but pricey. We had the opportunity to ride around... More

My husband and I went for a weekend getaway ... Customer service was horrible, rooms smelled bad and were dirty, food wasn't that great . This place never specified that it was pet friendly we had to be switched in 1 hour to 3 different rooms, if you own a pet and don't mind the dog hair and the stale... More

This place is a St Tropez like ! I spent 2 nights with my wife last summer. The concept is very relaxing. It reminds me St Tropez boutique hotel. You need to make your reservation in advance to have the privilege to have a room. I will come back this summer !

Beautiful property, European atmosphere, crappy service. The breakfasts were excellent but dinner was hit or miss, either really good or really bad. Customer service is non-existent, staff is just not friendly or attentive. Loved the balcony of my room - lovely view. The room could have been nicer, it's like they're trying too hard to be cool. The clientele is... More

Honestly read every review below mine, as I will NOT need to write much, as everyone below has said it just as I would have. Horrible rooms, extremely dirty, outdated, and we felt like we needed to cover everything with our own towels we thankfully brought. I wish I had brought my own sheets and pillowcases, but really..... how would... More

My now-husband and I had the most incredible engagement weekend here last summer. We go to Shelter Island annually and it's always a great time, but this was our first stay at Sunset, and it was over the top. From the location to the staff, food, our room and the amenities, we were well taken care of and more than... More

I stayed in the Sunset Beach hotel this past weekend for two nights with my wife and two children. I stayed at this hotel based on two recommendations from friends who have homes out East. The both have not stayed in the hotel, though spoke very highly.. I normally never ever write or post reviews.. Make that never, though I... More

I should have listened to the other reviewers who said this hotel wasn't worth the money. I absolutely had to the worst vacation ever. The hotel is overpriced, the accomodations subpar and the staff is quite rude. I can't comprehend how the owners of this place justify charging European prices, mistakenly trying to pass themselves as a French Riviera hotel.... More

Shelter Island is a wonderful place to visit in the summer. I recommend anyone to visit Shelter Island. If you decide to visit the Sunset Beach Resort on Shelter Island, don't expect to receive the level of treatment one would expect based on their pricing. The resort is all about the staff. We arrived at 3:00PM, normal check-in time at... More