Just returned from 4 night stay at the Tregarthen Hotel. We too had read previous mixed reviews but have nothing but praise. Our room overlooked the harbour. The food was excellent especially the evening meals. We could have been in a Michelin restaurant the way the food was presented. It was out of this world. The staff couldn't have been... More

We have just returned from a 4 day stay at the Tregarthen and wanted to say what a fantastic time we had during our stay. With a mixed bag of reviews we were unsure what to expect. However we have nothing but positive things to say. The room, spacious and with excellent views- surely the best room in the hotel.... More

Having stayed on St Mary's three times and each time at Tregarthens, I can fully recommend the hotel for great service, food and a perfect location. The rooms have been recently renovated and look great. I look forward to my next visit. More

The best kept secret in the UK is the Isle of Scilly, I have just come back from my 15th visit and for the last 13 of them I have stayed at Tregarthens', the best position, the finest food, newly refurbished rooms, friendly and helpful staff, there is know better place to stay. More

Just had a fantastic short break with a group of friends on the Isles of Scilly, with a memorable stay at Tregarthens. All the staff were so friendly and welcoming - the management have such a good team working there. The food was superb, from the classic full English breakfast to the delicious four course dinner in the evening. I... More

I organise a large group of travelers which means I take credit when things go well and responsibility (and grief) when they don't. As such, being able to stay at Tregarthen's is not only hugely enjoyable but also an enormous weight off my shoulders. Nothing is too much trouble, and Ben (the GM) and his team really do put themselves... More

I don't normally write reviews for superb locations as they might become too popular! However, we have just returned from another short break on Scilly and we stayed, for the 11th time, at Tregarthens. Throughout this time, service has aways been impeccable. I look forward to my smoked haddock and poached eggs breakfast - absolutley first class. Evening meals are... More

I come back to Scilly every year with friends and for the last 12 or so years have always stayed at Tregarthens. The welcome from the management and staff is always first class and nothing is too much trouble, its just like visiting old friends but with outstanding food, company and service every night. This year I stayed in one... More

It always amazes me that more people haven't discovered the beauty of the Scilly Isles, right on our doorstep. I come back with friends every year and we always stay at Tregarthens. The position is perfect, overlooking the mouth of the picturesque harbour, convenient for everywhere. I can't fault the manager and the staff, always helpful and friendly (even when... More