I can't praise the folks at Island Club Rentals enough, for friendliness and service. Twice I've stayed in their rentals, and both times had an absolute blast. Everything about the stay was great and we were treated incredibly well no matter our requests. The houses are well-kept and comfortable and I would stay there again.

We stay here every year twice a year! It is like our own little summer house for two weekends out of the year. Jerry, Dottie, Paul, and Tony have always gone out of their way for us! They get us whatever supplies etc we need without question. The service that we recieve from everyone at the island club is over... More

My visit to Put in Bay & Stay At Island Club including the staff was Outstanding, Looking forward to next year. There are plenty of things to do on the Island such as boating, fishing, touring by pedal bike, motorized bike, golf cart or the tour train. There are plenty of shops, minature golf, eateries to enjoy. All cottages have... More

This is our 4th year attending the Spring Fling Party and staying at The Island Club. I love the location and the fact that if you do need to get anywhere, there is always a taxi available. Jerry and the rest of the staff are very helpful and always willing to help out with any requests you might have. Our... More

We stayed at Island Club for Spring Fling and we had the best time! Jerry was very welcoming and helpful-even gave us a tour around the island. Our house #108, was clean and comfortable. I felt very at home and will definitely come back soon. Thanks for a great weekend and first experience at PIB!

Jerry and the entire staff at the Island Club Resort were AMAZING! Super accommodating for any request we had, very helpful from booking until check out. We stay here every year that we can. From Bachelorette Parties to just quick weekends away, Island Club at Put In Bay is THE place to stay for any occasion!!!

We had a group of friends staying for a weekend in a house by the pool. It was nice to all stay together, but I will not be back to the Island Club. The house had definitely been partied-hard in. No garbage or anything, but broken furniture and holes in the dry wall. My college dorm bathroom was way cleaner.... More

the experience here is always great. great time, great people, great service. i wont stay anywhere else on the island. location is awesome, staff is friendly and is always there to help. GO ISLAND CLUB!

My first experience of Put-in-Bay was a couple weeks ago. I had no expectations but was impressed with the island and the Island Clubs staff (especially Dottie). They were extremely helpfull and very friendly. Met a tons of cool people and had a blast. If your looking for the Ritz Carlton your on the wrong island! We be returning next... More