This hotel is in downtown Put in Bay, and caters to the Party crowd. If you're used to 4 or 5 star accommodations, you may want to look elsewhere, but the rooms in this hotel are average though a bit small, and clean. The location is right in the middle of downtown, which means you can walk to restaurants, bars,... More

Spent the past weekend in Put-in-Bay for Octoberfest. The hotel was so overpriced-had a two night minimum. The room had not been dusted for sometime. The carpet in the hallway had cigerette burns. The decor was 70's. The sink to brush your teeth and wash you hands was in the entrance way of the room. No coffee maker- no conditioner-... More

My husband and I spent a weekend there. We booked a "double" room and had one double bed. Needless to say, it was like sleeping in a crib. Also, our room was on the first floor near the reception desk. Very Very noisy.. When people came back at night woke me up. And the room we had did not have... More

The location was great! BUT our room that had four beds had ants everywhere. They even came in and sprayed twice, but these suckers were tough! In the bathroom, on the nightstand, walls, and on the dresser. We try to stay at different places each time we come, and we will NOT stay here...If you like things crawling around your... More

I understand now that it is impossible to expect much more from a Put In Bay "resort" but I really expected a bit more from this destination. Not only do you get the very bare minimum (even out of season, apparently) you pay an astronmical amount to get nothing. I mean, seriously, how can you not have a coffee maker... More

Commodore is conveniently located in downtown within walking distance of everything. Has a pool with a bar in the pool as well as outside the pool. Subway is located inside hotel which makes it even nicer to grab a sandwich late at night. More

We found this room at the last minute as we realized the last ferry would leave the island at 5pm (for cars). The gentleman that checked us in was friendly and helpful, however forget to tell us that there isn't a hotel sign from either street. Consequently we drove around block 4 times. The room was perfect for a VERY... More

We booked this motel at the last minute, so we didn't check around much. This is an average motel but it is in a great location. We thought it was a little pricey for October, but the location made up for some of that. The room was clean and the staff was friendly. It is within walking distance to bars,... More

I'm totally surprised by the reviews I am reading. Put in Bay is an ADULT Island. It has nick names like Ohio Cancun and ADULT Disney World. A group of girls and I stayed three nights at Commodore Motel. We were in the newer section and it was great. It wasn't anything super special but it was worth it because... More