Recently Reviewed Hotels around Fire Island Pines

• The Madison Fire Island Pines
  "The Madison--A True Pines Oasis"
  "As a returning guest, I certainly can recommend The Madison. The rooms are spacious and nicely appointed. The common spaces are also very comfortable, inviting and great spaces to meet other guests who have become friends. Luke has created a serene atmosphere with the assistance of his team Mike and..." Tim. From the delicious breakfast each morning, to the afternoon frozen margaritas to the elegant candles that light the house, pool area, hot tub, roof decks and trees. Luke, Mike and Tim are always visible and making sure that each guest's stay is memorable and creating the resort feel. " More >
• The Madison Fire Island Pines
  "Superb Holiday Stay; Excellent Staff"
  "My best friend and I booked "Garden Bedroom B" this past Memorial Day Weekend, and had the BEST time both at FIP and at The Madison! Super-clean, super friendly staff and perks like frozen margaritas and fresh baked cookies, breakfast spread, etc. HIGHLY recommended! We will be back without any h..."esitation or doubt. If you are looking for someplace on Fire Island Pines, you can’t get a better Bed and Breakfast than this. All this and just steps away from all the action at the bay, but far enough away that you can’t hear any commotion. You have two solid promoters here! Eric W. and James N. from Miami Beach. " More >
• The Madison Fire Island Pines
  "Worth it!"
  "Two weekends ago, my partner and I ventured out to the Pines for the very first time and we chose to stay at The Madison. From the moment we walked up the lit pathway to the house, we knew we had made the right decision. Luke, the house manager, greeted us as we walked in and made us feel right at..." home within seconds. Luke is truly a gem and nothing I could write here would truly do him justice. He is 1 part concierge and 10 parts sweetheart - he quickly acquainted us with our surroundings and gave us the scoop on the best restaurants, bars, and activities. He cares for the home as if it were his own and he treats the guests as if they were friends visiting the island for a special occasion. His hospitality, along with that of Mike and Tim (the other house staff), is unparalleled and turned a chilly, rainy weekend into one that was exceptionally fun. Oh, and I guess I should also mention that the rooms are generously sized and the entire house was spotless even with guests track... " More >