We dined here for the third time in October. It was our third wonderful meal. The wine list is an attraction in itself, and the food is always excellent.
This place is special in every way. Food is excellent. Very creative and well prepared. The service is informed and very helpful without being invasive. The ambience is embracing, cozy and relaxing. There are lots of great restaurants on Nantucket. This one stands out.
Food is beyond fabulous!! American Season always offers imaginative, beautiful food and drink and an atmosphere that is welcoming and cozy. I always feel confident in sending people to AS and they always return with great reviews.
Our concierge offered American Seasons as a good choice for us on our first visit to Nantucket. While the atmosphere of the restaurant is romantic and charming, the service was terrible and the food disappointing. The woman who took our order was ludicrously officious. When she heard that only one of our party would be drinking wine (by the glass,... More
Jane, we are sorry to hear that you were not satisfied with your meal, I checked with the servers and managers and to their knowledge no-one let us know that they were unhappy with one of their meals portion size recently. Neither had a table to anyone's knowledge on staff waited an hour for a meal. We keep track of... More
The decor, dim lights and candles, is rather lovely if rather wintery. The service is excellent but sadly what is in your plate is disappointing, featuring lots of different ingredients that don't really fit together. Another Nantucket restaurant living on its reputation. There are much better choices.
Thank you for talking the time to review our restaurant, Michael and I are disappointed that you did not enjoy your time with us. We work in our restaurant every day and do not rely solely on our reputation, if we did not pay attention to our small family owned and operated business, we would no longer have a great... More
We really enjoyed our dinner here in the busy summer month of August. The food was delicious! It has a nice cozy atmosphere and loved the location in Nantucket town. Make sure you make reservations ahead, summer is busy in Nantucket.
My husband and I ate at American Seasons one night in September. I had the suckling pig and my husband had the cod. We shared the Carrot Terrine. Everything was very good. Nothing that quite tipped it over to the 5 star category for us, but a very nice evening.
American Seasons was amazing - creative, unusual, for the adventurous, though the timid would find options that they liked. Family of 5 (including our 3 sons aged 16-20 who are open to trying new things) had quite an experience eating unusual things (to them) and loving it! Charcuterie appetizer was so good we ordered another before getting half way through... More
Have been to American Seasons, but not for several years as I felt it had become a bit boring. Despite the mixed reviews we went back. We thought the place was outstanding. Still the same physical plant, which I agree is a bit cramped. We were on the patio which was very nice - albeit a bit cramped. The food... More
If you own or manage American Seasons, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing