If there is a scale of 1-10 this is a 50! They know what they are doing and between the fantastic rustic environment, effortless and perfect service-- it only adds to the fantastic food experience. The lobster was the best I've had...and I've had a lot. Don't miss this one. This is clearly the best restaurant on Nantucket.

The reservation required well in advance is worth it. Interesting business model -- two seatings only, prix fixe menu published that week, and limited wines by the glass (so if you're not up for a bottle or 1/2 bottle of fairly expensive wine...) But the meal was really, really delicious! Pricey and worth it!

The food was good,but we were only offered one option for dinner on Christmas Stroll weekend. If you didn't like beef ......

This restaurant has great food, exceptional service and a wonderful romantic atmosphere. The menu, seating times and prices are fixed. We have consistently had very good delicious food at this restaurant and it is always the highlight of our dining experience during Christmas Stroll Weekend. Their wine list is good, but pricey (least expensive red was $75+), not much in... More

A beautiful atmosphere in a romantic and cozy space, Company of the Cauldron is intimate and special. We chose to dine on a Thursday night after reviewing the dinner options for each night (one set menu is posted for each night of the week, with each course set). Reservations are a must as this is a small restaurant. Every table... More

We went for the Thurs, 10/18 menu (menus are posted in advance are change daily). The food and service was excellent, as were the wine selections Our only negative was that the room was very crowded and noisy, so it was sometimes difficult to speak to or hear my wife, accross the table - or when the server was explaing... More

I had booked this before our holiday and was glad as he place was fully booked on the night we were there. The restaurant has a set menu with no choices - I love this idea and wish others would follow. Do one thing and do it well. Really great courses. Wine selection also good but liqueurs limited if you... More

I love the concept of a different meal each evening and one seating. The food was expertly prepared and the servers explained each plate as it was served. The restaurant puts the weekly menu online and also on the wall of the restaurant. The atmosphere was romantic with candlelight and only about 15 tables that I could see. Very expensive... More

The appetizer was a pasta with shrimp and smoked mozzarella ... and was amazing... The Beef slices with green beans and mashed potatoes were delicious.... superb even..topped off with a panna cotta dessert that was next to heaven.... worth every dime and more...and did I mention the inside is charming.... just lovely...