I don't know if they have the thick crust, too, but their thin crust pizzas are perfect. Lots of choices, tasty toppings, lots of tables - a great place to take kids or just to grab a bite before theatre. I had take-out. The only drawback of take-out is that there is no good parking. They do not deliver..

We stopped in for a quick bite before the matinee at OSF. Really good thin slice veggie pizza served with a fresh salad and a drink. The other diners present with whole pizzas on the table looked pretty satisfied too.

I'm a pizza snob. I admit it. We've been to Martolli's 4 times (we don't live in Ashland) and honestly we liked ot a lot better the first few times. We last went on Memorial Day weekend Sunday. Service was slow (they weren't very busy) the girl operating the register was visibly frazzled, they got our order wrong. They had... More

I burned dinner so we called and ordered a large pizza, half Big Ben, half Combination. Deelish. Negative: It was slower to be ready than I was told on the phone. But not much.

I'm not supposed to eat pizza - too many calories, salt, etc. - but I also manage to arrange my intake so I can sink into the ecstasy of a good slice here. The veggie slice is different veggies each time, so it's always an adventure. Huge slices make a meal for anyone who's not a full-time athlete, a teenager... More

This place was packed when we arrived, and then as soon as we sat down the place emptied out. We just ordered a slice. It was fine, but not that big, so not very filling for $3.50 a slice.

I come from Brooklyn, NY, and I admit to being a pizza addict and fanatic. NY pizza is still my favorite, but it's almost impossible to find outside of NY (believe me, I've tried). I don't know how these guys do it, but their hand-tossed pizza is the best I've had outside of NY. The crust is perfect for folding... More

I always make it by here when I am in Ashland. I usually grab a slice when walking around and get a half baked to heat up at home. just real good hand tossed pizza you can't go wrong.

I love this place! Eat-in is always delicious, I usually get a salad and a slice, reasonably priced. And just recently I got a pizza for take out and was really satisfied. I can't wait to try all of their specialty pies!