The New Sheridan Chop House in Telluride, Colorado has a good menu and a great atmosphere. Unfortunately I am on a gluten free diet and was met with resistance and rudeness for the two times I have tried the restaurant. During my first visit I ate dinner at the bar. The bartender checked with the kitchen to find out what... More

Loved the menu choices. From Elk steaks to 30 day dry aged Bison. Had great service, drinks and food. Very historic sheridan building with the dining side having been restored. The bar side has been left 90% original according to the bartender. We would love to go back.

We were in for dinner on 3-19-13. We have eaten here many other times and have never been disappointed. On this night I had the elk loin, which was perfectly cooked and delicious, my husband had a NY strip, also perfect. The other couple dining with us had a filet and the bison, both of which were cooked perfectly and... More

Had a great burger here and my husband had the bison which was delicious. A little pricey for meals but a good place to stop in for a drink as well. Also check out the bar next door.

We had a really nice dinner at the Chop House. The place is pretty and the service was great. We decided to split one of the 20oz Bone In Ribeyes & added a lobster tail to it so we could try a few other things on the menu and not be overstuffed. That was a great way to go! The... More

The Chop House certainly could rest on its historic building and elegant dining room for patrons in the charming town of Telluride, but it doesn't; in fact, we so enjoyed our experience we went back repeatedly. Ray Farnworth, the hotel's GM does a remarkable job in ensuring that the experience and the food are spot on. Steaks are the main... More

Our party of four really enjoyed this restaurant. While nothing was blow your socks off great, everything was very good and service was very acceptable for a ski town place. Wine list was good, but too heavy on the big price labels and not entirely accurate with their current stock on hand. We skipped dessert. No complaints, and we all... More

Dinner at the New Sheridan was flawless. The great Western feel of the place was matched by competent service and, hands down, the best elk I have ever had. They are known locally for the best prepared game in town and they didn't disappoint. My kids had the salmon and they thought that was excellent. I can't remember what my... More

Great service, first-class fare. We loved the steaks and returned twice for supper and twice for breakfast! Nice dinning room, good cocktails and helpful waiting staff.