We have eaten at this restaurant several times in the past. The food has always been good but tonight we decided to order delivery. We ordered our food at 5:15 and never received it. We called the place TWICE but the owner only said it was on it's way. After a TWO HOUR + wait we just called and cancelled... More

We eat here on a fairly regular basis and love the food! Prices are reasonable and atmosphere is friendly. It's not a luxury establishment but is very comfortable and family friendly. Eggplant Parmesan is excellent!

My family had enjoyed this place in the past, but a recent visit had poor service, and food that seemed to be microwaved and undercooked. I asked for a house white wine, was served a red, and while it was replaced, I was charged for both. We had difficulty with drink refills, and while the restaurant was nearly empty during... More

This place seems like a slice of New Jersey neighborhood Italian in Windsor, Colorado. Pauly, the owner, seems to be always there welcoming people. The pizza and pizza rolls are good. The red sauce for pasta is excellent. The prices are quite reasonable. For Italian in Windsor, our choice in the Italian Grill.

The Italian Grill has a great value for their family take home dinner - a bucket of spaghetti, bread, and salad for $20. Good, homemade food! Eating in is a pleasure, too. Personable service paired with what you expect in an Italian restaurant - great food!

We had the special of the evening which was lasagne, a side of spaghetti with a meatball, bread, salad and dessert. Cost was $15.95. The lasagne was mainly sauce and cheese with very little meat or noodles. You almost needed a spoon to eat it, so I treated it as a dippng sauce for the bread which was very good.... More

Is there a zero circle rating? The manager is a violent weirdo! Food was crap. I'd eat a lean cuisine for dinner before I go back there. Upon telling the waitress that the chicken tasted burnt and the noodles were doughy and undercooked and the food was lukewarm while the plate was scalding, she took it away (that's what happens... More

As a Chicagoland native I have been searching for authentic Italian pizza in my area for a number of years and can happily say my search is finally over. We ordered Paulie's Pomadori Special Pizza and it was wonderful. The crust melts in your mouth and it is just as good when eaten cold the next morning for breakfast. We... More

It's not the greatest Italian food you will find, but the service is excellent, the dessert canoli's are wonderful, and the portions are generous. My family loves to eat here, and the value for the buckets of pasta can't be beat. It's cheaper to eat her than any fast food restaurant in town.