Excellent italian food in a little strip mall across the street from a motel. Portions are large and my husband and I shared a pear salad and a seafood pasta dish with clams, mussels, scallops, tuna and salmon in a very light tasty sauce. The other couple with us had the tuna spinach dish and proclaimed that it was the... More

Well, not going to lie. Being from NY I had no faith in the meal I was going to consume. Considering I already drove 2 hours in bumper to bumper traffic I wanted to just fill my stomach and go to bed. Well, we arrived and ordered Calamari which was OUT OF THIS WORLD. I understand that they may have... More

We were a little alarmed to arrive on a Saturday night at 6pm to see that the restaurant was almost empty - never a good sign. We were of course seated immediately. No cocktail menu so I had ask for a "fruity tasting" martini - crass I know but what can I tell you - I like sweet drinks.... Hubby... More

Tiberio's has a welcoming staff and a very competent chef. Dinner here is clearly a cut above what you will find in many Connecticut Italian restaurants. The food is fairly basic and straightforward but is consistently delicious. The portions are ridiculously large, so think seriously about sharing plates. The chef is also very flexible about handling requests: last night we... More

Tiberio's Restaurant is a diamond in an area that boasts many fine dining experiences. I took my wife there for our tradional New Years Eve dinner and she absolutey loved it. It is tucked inconspiciously in a small strip mall. That being said turn on your GPS and visit this gem. Ambiance there is great (creative decorating for sure) with... More

The restaurant is under new management & I am pleased to find they haven't lost great quality or service. Our dinners were delicious & the service was excellent. The owner/chef came to our table & talked with us which I thought was very nice. I would highly recommend this restaurant & we will definitely return!

We stopped off at this restaurant on the way back from a concert in Old Lyme. It's easy to miss since it's tucked away in a shopping center which it shares with Action Sports. Upon arrival we were seated almost immediately. Drink orders were promptly served, and fresh bread promptly brought to our table- with three spreads, one of which... More

On the recommendation of someone who lives in Old Saybrook, we tried Tiberio's for my birthday dinner and what a great experience we had! We made reservations for 8:30 on a Saturday night. We were greeted at the door by the owner's daughter who pleasantly welcomed us. We were seated promptly and put in our beverage order as we looked... More

Don't let the exterior fool you, the restaurant is in a small strip mall. I've had multiple meals here. All were excellent. Well priced. Quality food. Worth a visit again and again.