Once we discovered it we just kept coming back! I HIGHLY recommend the Coffee Toffee! This place is always busy. The staff are friendly and quick to help. Really good ice cream! Definitely have to stop by if your in the area. And be sure to sign their guest books (cool idea for visitors from across the country).

It's remarkable how many different flavors of ice cream are made at this small, always-crowded place! After coming to Fort Myers for years, we came here for the first time just the other day; the portions are huge (the "small" is anything but!), and the ice cream is delicious. This is definitely a "must-try." Great place, and wading through the... More

If you are looking for delicious creamy rum and raisin ice-cream on the way to Fort Myers Beach – look no further.

Had the black cherry twice on our trip to Sanibel Island. They give you so much ice cream for a small price and it is delicious. The second time we went was right after dinner at Island Cow on Sanibel. As we pulled up, we noticed that the couple sitting next to us at Island Cow was now sitting out... More

Apparently Love Boat Ice Cream is quite an institution in Fort Myers. I've heard about the place from several different people. And they were all right. Huge selection, friendly stuff, great prices. Anybody from 3 years old to 100 years old visiting Fort Myers must try Love Boat Ice Cream.

This is the place to get your ice cream in Fort Myers. Many Many choices. Also the prices are not high unlike the Stone or the Queen

This is a must for me every time I visit Ft Myers, Homemade ice cream in lots of flavors. I make sure to purchase a couple dishes to take home with me - after having a cone there first. :) The ice cream is rich and delicious! It is a fun stop - kids of all ages would love it.

Stopped by because our Grandkids come here from Philly to vacation with their parents. Delicious & quite an assortment of yummy homemade flavors. Decent sized cones, moderately priced & dipping temperature good. Fun interior & outside seating too. Friendly staff. See my photos.

We had ice cream here twice in three days. A great selection of very good ice cream at very reasonable prices. The first night we had the regular cups of ice cream for a price of $4. Excellent choices but probably a little too much sweetness in one sitting for the normal appetite. The second stop this weekend we chose... More