Totally overpriced. The crab in the stir fry and the chowder both seemed to be imitation crab. Barely ate anything. Wished we had gone somewhere else. Staff did not speak or understand English very well.
More

Totally overpriced. The crab in the stir fry and the chowder both seemed to be imitation crab. Barely ate anything. Wished we had gone somewhere else. Staff did not speak or understand English very well.
More
I can see why people travel miles to this resturant.
A selection from: Snow Clab leks/Oysters/Shrimp/Salad Bar/Pialla/Roast Beef/Chicken etc.
If fact around 80 different things to eat all for a set price.
This is our first visit having been to the key over 30 times, we will come back next year to fill up again!
A set price and all...
More
It only gets a 'meh' because my girl friend liked it.
Stick to the raw bar, seems to be the only thing worth eating.
The prepared seafood is the same stuff you buy at Costco in the frozen section. And you'll spend more time picking bones and cartilage out of your mouth than chewing on fried snapper.
Nothing fancy but...
More
Lookef nice, food ok, wait staff great, roach in iced tea bad. Told waiter and he saw it and took it to management. He stopped by while wife and friend went outside to loose dinner
He said he was sorry, we told him that stuff happens but it was not cool. Again with the sorry, maybe if we were locals...
More
The all-you-can eat buffet is definitely good and the value is there. With such a wide selection of food, I would think anyone can find something they like. Most of us find too many foods that we like!
More
We used to come here when we wanted a bit of everything--seafood as well as chicken, beef, etc. However, our most recent visit was our last. The restaurant was dirty and damp, the service non-existent, and the food had that dry, heat-lamp taste.
More
So much to choose from; deep fried crab cakes, paella, raw or steamed oysters, crab legs, baked fish prepared several different ways, clams in garlic butter, seafood salads of all kinds, and desserts. I loved the crab cakes and smoked fish salad. The price is $29.95, but so worth it! You will have to drag yourself out of this place.
More
Get there when the fishing boats come in to see the fresh catch. Then have yourself a cocktail upstairs at the bar overlooking ocean. Fabulous!!
More
Be ready to eat lots of food, so delicious. Great for a group or family gathering.
More
Great place to have a cocktail and watch the charters come in from an all day trip! Some of the catches will blow you away! Will make you want to book a charter!!!
More
If you own or manage Whale Harbor Inn, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing