Even if the line is out the door, it is well worth the wait. Definitely was the best black raspberry I have ever had! I can't wait to go back next summer and try some more of thier amazing flavors!!

With all the ice cream places on Martha's Vineyard, a place would really need to have top notch ice cream or something else special going for it to catch our attention. We gave Mad Martha's a try and were wrong to waste our time. The ice cream served was not as good as other places we tried later and the... More

Their two scoop cups are substantial, an delicious! I had coconut and Oreo cream...both were good. A highlight for our group was that they have an operational Juke Box that still uses records! It was the first time my daughter had seen a record and gave us a special experience to go along with the ice cream.

OMG, I mean OMG, the best chocholate chip and mint chocolate chip ice cream I ever had. MY GOSH...I am still dreaming about this place. Wow, this is Vinyard Haven's best kept secret. We had a choice of places but the "home made" sold me/us so we have no regrets. I didnt want to do anything but enjoy the moments.... More

Had the Sinful Sunday Ice Cream. Staff is a bit unfriendly and when we wanted to sample an ice cream it was as if we were bothering them (they would roll the eyes make a sound and be like so which one you want real nasty) so we just ended up with the one that seemed to be asked for... More

Good enough but nothing special for homemade ice cream. Maybe it was an off day since it was the Monday of labor day - but I was disappointed

I love Mad Martha's. When I'm on the island, I usually try to eat here every day. Gotta have my dairy. All I their favors are fantastic. My favorites are blueberry, butter crunch and mint Oreo (my favorite ice cream flavor ever). Their scoops can be pricey -- 4 or 5 bucks a cone an they are cash only so... More

If you like ice cream than this is the place for you...homemade!! If you don't like it, you will after just one cup or cone!

Have tried most of the ice-cream parlors on Martha's Vineyard, and have found that Mad Martha's is absolutely awesome.