Friendly wait staff, Lots of menu choices, steak, chicken, seafood.... Large glasses of wine at a fair price. . Casual.

small portions on the smothered steak, average size on the big apple n.y strip service was ok but waitress never came back to the table after serving us. oh and my wife found a small bone chip in the smothered steak about the size of a dime.also small and crowded tables are too close together.

Heard that Gatsbys offered excellent steak but we were very dissapointed. 3/4 of us ordered the ribeye. They all came out cold and not done right (the medium steak came out rare and another came our well done). We had to send the steaks back and yet it just didn't taste good. I doubt they even put any seasoning on... More

My fiance took me here on our weekly date and we fell in love with it!! Great food and an awesome atmosphere! It's a really neat place and we hope to go there regularly! Can't wait to go back! Check this place out for sure.

Atmosphere, ambiance and you're back in the roaring 20's. Tiffany lamps, cozy lighting with a great looking bar where you can hold a conversation without shouting in the old downtown section of Bay City. The Tommy gun and felt fedora on the wall lent a note of authenticity The house salad was very fresh, lettuce was crispy with excellent salad... More

Went with the review choices and had filet mignon. Great choice as was the porterhouse my husband ordered! Salad was fresh and twice baked potato topped off a wondetful meal!

Good kids menu. Steaks, chicken, ribs and sandwiches are the best in the area. Homemade soup is always a pleasure. Thanks.

A week ago, My wife Susan and I were looking for something different for dinner on Friday night. We went to one restaurant that had a wait of over an hour (a real food factory). Sue mentioned Gatsby's in downtown Bay City. Being from the area, we hadn't eaten there before so we decided it sounded good. We were pleasantly... More

We stayed one night in Bay City on our honeymoon and were looking for somewhere to have a good steak dinner. We drove to all the main restaurants, they were all packed with long wait times. So glad they were, or we wouldn't have had the excellent meal that we did. We happened to pass Gatsby's on the way back... More