great food, wonderfull stuff cant wait to go back....

I eat at mystic island pizza ALL OF THE TIME!! My boyfriend lives right around the corner & we order constantly. All of the food is really really tasty but I prefer the Sicilian pizza with marinara sauce & the meatball parm sub! YUM! I've never had bad service, prices or bills. Really great restaurant.

I don't recall the exact time within the last year that I order 2 large cheese steaks, so I am just adding the present time as the date of our visit. I just want to let people know that when I ordered 2 large cheese steaks, I thought they would be about $7 - $8 each. Boy was I shocked... More

I was pleasantly surprised by the taste of the food of this pizza place. We ordered for delivery a large meat lover's pizza, a medium cheese pizza, linguini with clam sauce, hot wings, spaghetti with meatballs, eggplant parmigiana, and fried calamari. Everything was delicious especially the fried calamari...we couldn't get enough of it. Delivery was prompt and courteous. I won't... More

I definitely think the other reviewer had the wrong restaurant! We have been loyal customers of Mystic Island Pizza for almost 7 years. Their food is delicious. We have had numerous family and friends visit over the years, and we always order from Mystic. It is hard to choose a favorite. We love their penne vodka, cheesesteak calzones, mozzerella sticks,... More

It Must have been a bad night for me..Before Ordering my Pizza i looked up a couple pizza places around town since i am new in this area after reading most of the reviews i decided to order from mystic island pizza well my pizza was cold and my french fries were soggy never will i order from there again!

Their pizza is pretty good, the people are very nice. I wanted something that is not on the menu and they made it for me. We like it there.

WORSE place EVER. I just ordered diner there and found a COCKROACH in my food. After calling them, they offered to make me a new Stromboli. ARE you kidding me? I demanded my money back and called the board of health. After puking several times, I wanted to warn everyone else about this place. THEY ARE DIRTY n NASTY. DO... More

I dine at Mystic PIzza at least twice a week....being a local and hate to cook. Food is excellent, the service is very friendly and warm. Great family owned business. They are responsible for at least ten pounds around my middle!