Cam's is the best little pizza place in Penn Yan...you won't be disappointed :) Be sure to try their buffalo chicken pizza!

Cam's is the best little pizza place in Penn Yan...you won't be disappointed :) Be sure to try their buffalo chicken pizza!
Caustic sauce. Still, people in Geneva go there. It's a matter of taste, I guess. Cams isn't to my t sate in pizza.
We stopped here after a day of hitting the wineries. The location seems a little on the run down side, but the pizza was decent. The sit down area wasn't the cleanest, but we have definitely seen worse. If you are just looking for a quick bite to eat without care of the atmosphere, this is an OK choice.
We hard a hard time finding this place because trip advisor had the address wrong (it's 476 Exchange Street Geneva NY-close to a corner on the main drag). We're glad we did. The pizza was thin crust and covered with meat (we are allergic to cheese). The subs were full and very tastey. Will definitely visit this place next time...
More
Six booth seats are inside. I ate inside not knowing that. Really it is a take out place. I had to use a pocket knife to cut the crust – it was not overdone, just doughy and dense. My peperoni and onion had less than two pieces of peperoni per slice – they are big slices -- and the onion...
More
I've been eating Cams' pizza and wings since I was a child (I am currently 32), and it is my favorite, hands down. If you like thin, New York style pizza with a flavorful sauce, a perfect dough consistency, and tasty pepperoni, then you are in for a treat.
Great wings, too.
Go here...you will not be disappointed (get delivery,...
More
Great pizza by the slice or whole pie. As close to NYC pizza as your gonna find in up-state ny. Good subs also on there own bread. to-go or eat in, order early this place gets busy.
I love Cam's pizza! For some reason, it always tastes the best when I order the XL size. I think they may use the same amount of dough as the L but they stretchhhh it further making the crust even thinner and better! Wish we had a source for thin crust pizza like this in Canandaigua.
Probably a good idea to get the pizza to go and sit down by the lake and enjoy a wonderful, thin crust pie. Always busy and always hopping.
Their slices are the real deal. It's a great late night local spot
If you own or manage Cams New York Pizzeria, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing