This was the 2nd highest pizza joint rated on TA, so after a long weekend and not feeling like going out to eat, we decided to just bring in some pizza. We've never had luck finding a local place, but instead of going with the chains we can get at home we gave this place a try. After placing an... More

We always stop here when we come to the outer banks. The pizza is delicious. There are other menu items if you don't want pizza. Prices are reasonable and service is good.

We go here every year usually early evening. Good food & friendly family atmosphere! Calzones and pizzas are super delicious. Calzones can be shared with 2 people. Recommend highly!

Pizza was good. We ordered grilled chicken pesto pizza. The 14" was plenty for two hungries! Service was great. We went in around 11 on a Saturday morning so it was absolutely empty.

This place is one of the best-kept secrets on the banks. The decor leaves something to be desired, but don't let appearances fool you. My grandmother used to live on the OBX when I was growing up and we used to go to NYPP quite a bit. During a recent Sunday trip to the area, I decided to stop back... More

Although we had to wait to get in, the pizza we ordered was very good. There was a magician going around from table to table, but we could have done without him. We would go back for the pizza.

To be honest, I would pay $10 for the pizza I paid $15 for at NYPP, but my local pizzeria isn't on the Outer Banks. My 10-year old isn't into a lot of toppings, so we had to settle for half cheese/half pepperoni. The pizza was as good as back home, but our waiter was outstanding. He was very attentive... More

Biker Friendly! Great food! Great staff! Genuine New York Style Pizza! Love Love Love It! Family joined us and they were so amazed, they called over the manager and expressed their satisfaction and appreciation!

This restaurant was our second favorite while vacationing in the OBX. Food was delicious, server was excellent.....I had the spaghetti and meatball special, now I am picky when it comes to sauce and this was fantastic !!!! My hubby has stuffed shells and Italian sausage he said it was delicious, I had a taste and he was right !!!