I was hesitant to eat here since there were no cars in the lot, but the food was good. Had an old fashioned BLT with fries and enjoyed every bite of it!

Loved everything about it, friendly service, interesting decor and great food. Probably the best restaurant potato salad I've ever had.

We lived on the island during off season and had dinner here at least every other week. I loved that there was a lot of home cooking on the menu. The liver and onions was pretty good and my fiancé loved the hamburger steak. My favorite was the fried pork chops. They were always cooked perfectly with a slightly crunchy... More

Very good coffee. Nice waitress served us. Food was pretty much your normal breakfast food. They were out of some kind of breakfast meat and the waitress was so apologetic. Too cute. You would have thought the world ended. I liked the location - pretty much on residential road in between houses. Would definitely recommend. Better than Marias for breakfast.

we have been to Chincoteague two times and enjoyed it! The first year we went to Mr. Baldy's and loved it. The second year we went, the food wasn't as good. the quality decreased. We still enjoyed it though.

My family and I vacation often to chincoteague and Mr. Baldy's is a must see for us when we are here. We visited last week it was kind of quiet but it's february so what do you expect. I got the double play which is kinda like the slam at denny's. my mom got the corned beef hash and my... More

waitress comes out with my husbands lunch, and informs me they do not have turkey. I ordered a club sandwich. We were given a bad referal to Mr. Baldy,s. I don't care for diner type foods, this is what it is. the roast beef my husband had was poor quality. there menu is mostly fried and fatty foods, just not... More

We have enjoyed the meals we've had here. The food is like food you would cook at home. Reasonable prices, especially on the daily specials.

Stopped in for supper. No one enjoyed their food as it was overpowered by onions in the food. We ordered different items and it all tasted like onions. Told the waitress but she didn't care. Went to pay and they added someone else's order to ours and was going to make us pay for it. Finally after 15 mins they... More