Very cool atmosphere, with a diffrent selection than what we're used to in the area. If you're looking for something diffrent try the Creole! The pizza is very good to! For my last visit I had the lasagna and it was excellent. I hate to say, I didn't have any left to take home!

We always try to eat in local places when we travel. Lake Mills only has a few places, so we used TA to pick the Blue Moon. We were greeted in a very friendly way, had great wait service, and HUGE portions of food. Neither of us were able to finish our meal. We both had Italian dishes. The price... More

If you're hungry and can wait, Blue Moon is the place to go in Lake Mills. It takes awhile to make the pizza (consider calling ahead, usually 30-40 minutes to bake) but it is worth the wait.

My wife had the lasagna, which was pretty decent. I had the Blue Moon Creole, which was basically jambalaya - I've had better, but it was very flavorful and quite good. I felt the decor was a little odd, because it seemed like they had a couple different themes going on - they had the whole New Orleans atmosphere and... More

We absolutely love Blue Moon pizza! We are new to the area & were absolutely thrilled to find pizza this delicious in a relatively small town. If we get a craving to order pizza, this is the only place we order from! The crust is wonderfully soft and crispy. The toppings are generous. They bake the pizza perfectly. We haven't... More

Had to wait for service from the waitress for a long time. Service was terrible. The food once it arrived was good. If you have hours to wait it's fine. Good food long wait for service.

the seafood alfreado has at least 30 shrimp and scallops. the pizza is to die for the best around

Good service, good burgers and beer. Good company, right down town on the square

Food was great and reasonably priced. Waitress was terrible, but the food made up for the bad service!