Wow! What a pleasant surprise! Went here to eat 2 night ago while in the area on business. It's small, quaint and wonderful. Turned an old house into a pizza place! Service was good...the waitress was extremely pleasant and funny. She made great recommendations as this was our first time there. Side salads were huge and homemade dressing great! Pizza... More

Simply real and fantastic pizza and sauce, and dipping sauce. Real veggies with natural flavored. During your visit you are literally at home in a living room. You will be near your fellow eaters and should like that. Don't bring your aloof aunt from Beverly Hills. Expect a family style greeting at the door and personal care from the waitress.... More

this pizza is amazing if I lived closer I would never go anywhere else for it. however the place does look like a house is somewhat hard to find.

You don't need to go to Chicago for great pizza-we have it right here in Sparta! Great food! Great service!

Located in an older residential building the dining area is quite small. But the pizza makes up for any wait time you may have. Cute decor. They do a lot of takeouts also.

It was so good we ate there two days in a row! Loved it! I wish I would have gotten the girls name that waited on us (thin with glasses and long auburn hair). She was super nice and even remembered the kind of beer I had ordered the day before. We just moved to Sparta and will definitely be... More

I go here every time I am at FT McCoy! The pizza is amazing! In my opinion it is the best in Wisconsin. It is an old house and it is like eating pizza at your grandma's house. They also serve up ice cold beer in mason jars. If you happen to be within 60 miles of Sparta, then you... More

If you're headed to Sparta from one of the many "Rails to Trails" bike trails, be sure to stop at "Slice of Chicago" to fuel up. It's exactly what you want: no frills - tasty - PIZZA. (In a house.)

Went here with my mom and husband. Was pleasantly surprised. It is located in an old house. The decor leaves something to be desired, but who cares when the pizza is great? As soon as we opened the door we were greeted with the wonderful smell of garlic. We started with bread sticks which were thick, twisted peices of dough... More