We went here because of the cute name, and will go back because of the great people and great food! The omelette was great, and atmosphere was very relaxed.

Good clean place execellent staff and good value tasty food my only complaint is there tables for four people are more so the size of two my family and I could barely sit comfortably at those small tables otherwise 5 star

On a snowy morning in Bayfield, this was a great stop for us. Good food and good service. Their Crabby Benny, a Eggs Benedict recipe featuring crabcakes, is quite good.

Breakfast here everyday. Fast service and damned good food! I did get a kick out of the pricey Maple syrup, but then again, you get what you pay for! And yes, I bought it and yes it was worth it!

Four of us ate at the Egg Toss for breakfast for both mornings in Bayfield. It has decor from the 50's, is bright & CLEAN. Friendly employees, great service & best of all DELICIOUS food with many choices. All four of us so impressed, we returned and would eat there every morning if there longer.

We ate at the Egg Toss for the first time this summer and it was very good. Be sure to bring a hearty appetite as they feed you enough to last the entire day!

We had a very basic breakfast of eggs and toast with coffee and eveything except the coffee was very enjoyable. We find that most US restaurants we have been too over the years serve weak coffee compared to what we usually are served here in Canada so my criticism of the coffee is not specific to this delightfull restaurant. McDonald's... More

We went to the Egg Toss on 2 different mornings on a recent vacation. On Sunday, the place was busy but steady, had a gracious host, attentive server & excellent breakfast. The next day, I thought I was in a different restaurant! The restaurant was slightly more busy (we had to wait around 10 minutes), no host, & 2 servers... More

we ate here the moring we left bayfield.we had the crappy benny it was very good.it is a crab cake with eggs on top .they also have bakery goods did not try but looked good.very clean and great serivce