My wife and I eat here on our last day in NYC before leaving for the airport. It was just round the corner from our hotel and lucky we only found it then because we would have eaten there every day and not tried anywhere else! The atmosphere on a Tuesday lunchtime was buzzing - a real diverse mix of... More

We were with a group and the food was pre-ordered. All of it was very good. We especially liked the Veal with mushrooms. We did not care for the shrimp dish. The deserts are fabulous. I would eat here again.

Simply stated... Carmine's serves huge portions that are very fresh and tasty. Service is attentive. The restaurant sits right in the center of the theater district, making it a perfect dining choice for before or after a show.

Two adults and 2 children could only eat half of one entrée and a third of the salad. We packaged it up and gave to the homeless. Good for a group and quite tasty.

With a group of friends, we visited Carmine's after seeing a show - great meal, big portions, friendly staff.

The atmosphere is great if you have a large family with kids. Since it is loud and family style dinning. Not where you want to bring someone for a romantic date. The food used to be better. I have noticed the busier the restaurant the worse the food was. We went the week of Christmas so you can only imagine... More

My family and I went to Carmines on a recommendation from a friend who used to perform on Broadway and it was definitely a good recommendation. My wife and I loved the food and our 9, and 11 year old though the food was good. We did not know were the restaurant was located when we booked or show but... More

I had made lunch reservations for a party of 2 and we were seated upstairs right away. We had a very friendly waitress who gave us some great ordering advice. The bread basket alone would have filled us up! My friend and I shared the Spiedini alla Romana appetizer and it was delicious (and unique). We then shared the Penne... More

Do not go with fewer than four people; there are no options for smaller groups, and it's a terrible waste of food and money.