I dont know all these people that wrote these reviews are on, but the pizza was really bad! The crust tasted like nothing!!! The rest of the toppings were ok but in no way makes up for the crust. We also ordered a salad that had brown lettuce and no dressing! One of the worst pizza places I have ever... More

Great people, food, and downtown location! And value is great, get cheap slices during lunch! You can choose your toppings and salads are good too!

Loved this pizza! Stopped here on a road trip from L.A. to Austin and couldn't be happier with the pizza. We got Gary's Special, which seemed like a normal supreme(pepperoni, homemade Italian sausage, onion, peppers, olives). As I type my mouth is watering thinking about this pizza. Plenty of toppings, fresh, crust good and not soggy. Beer selection also very... More

We were visitors in Flagstaff and asked the hotel for a pizza delivery recommendation (and not the big chains.) This was the one we tried. I found the sauce slightly spicy for my (admittedly mild/bland) taste. The crust was on the bread-y side, but tasted fresh and was good. It was not a particularly greasy pizza. We went for plain... More

The staff is friendly, the pizza is good with generous toppings, plus several good beer choices all for prices that make students happy. My only choice for Pizza when I'm in Flagstaff.

After reading the reviews here, my family and I stopped here looking for simple pizza and a salad. NI Marcos was an excellent choice. The pizza was superb; very good crust and sauce. This is definitely NOT your Pizza Hut type "pizza". The homemade pride is evident. I would recommend ordering ahead or be prepared to wait 30-45 minutes. They... More

Best place for families. Big selection. If you have a picky child, you can order a single slice of cheese and get a large of whatever you want. A large salad served as an appetizer for four of us with some left over. We had one large pizza and took home leftovers. They have good beers and a couple of... More

Tried this place based on reviews here, it was also featured in advertising in our hotel room. Loved the crust and the sauce. It was nice to be able to order a (big!) slice of cheese pizza for our 5 year old (he gave it a thumbs up) and a whole pizza for us. We had a 1/2 Gary's Special... More

We ordered from Nimarcos from our hotel during a snowstorm. They showed up within less than half an hour, and we especially appreciated their thoughtfulness in including condiments, napkins, everything! I was not crazy about the pizza though -- the box proclaims Nimarcos as having the best Flagstaff-style pizza and if that is true, I guess this in acquired taste.... More