Just got back from dinner at Pie Whole. Had to wait two days to get a reservation but it was so worth it! It's a tiny place, only about 6 tables & the bar, so don't expect to just walk it. We sat at the bar & Charlie the bar tender was fantastic! We ordered the cheese garlic bread and... More

The beer list is incredible. Don't ever just have one. I enjoyed the Urthel Saisonniere but I like the Flemish sour beer better...almost as much as I loved Samuel Smith's Chocolate Stout. The Baked Spinach and Artichoke Dip is an amazing app. Every pizza tastes brick-oven, and the hand-tossed crust is as perfect as it gets. I loved my Veg-Head... More

I ate here with my wife and kids our last evening in St Thomas. We ordered a pizza for the kids and my wife and I shared the Chip pasta dish. Both were very good. The beer list was VERY extensive. I have to admit, I was impressed. The service was very good and very friendly. The atmosphere was nice... More

One negative: Not the easiest to find in Frenchtown, with limited parking. On a positive note, I walked in, prepared to place a carry out order and the bartender was so pleasant, I decided to eat in & sat at the bar. It was not crowded b/c it was only 5:45pm, but the place filled up quickly. I ordered a... More

This was our second time eating at the Pie Whole - definitely top notch. When we return to St Thomas, this will always be on our agenda.

Got off to a real slow start as the food took 40 minutes to arrive. However, all the positive reviews we read kept us going and then........the chef -boy - dee pizza arrived. It would seem as though somebody started this amazing hoax some time ago and all the mindless people just followed along! The crust was paper thin, the... More

This place was over the top, but don't show up without a reservation. We ordered the spinach and artichoke appetizer. It was so good, I barely left room for the main course. i wouldn't miss out on this place when visiting st thomas.

Fantastic selection of beer and an owner who knows her beer!! My son and I frequently travel to St Thomas on dive trips. The Pie Whole became our home away from home. Thanx Laura!!

I live here, know good pizza when I eat it, and unquestionably, Pie Whole serves up the best pizza on St. Thomas - by far! They also have the most extensive list of beers St. Thomas has ever enjoyed. The only problem, is that Island pizza lovers know how great the pies are, so they're all here (i.e. there's always... More