Reservations accepted or needed for a Saturday night?
They do take reservations. There are plenty of eateries in downtown Riverhead within walking distance but Jerry's is the best. You won't go hungry there.
To be on the safe side, yes. Any restaurant would be busy on a Saturday night, and this one is next to a hotel and nothing much else around it. Also, I would venture the guess that it depends on the season.
Get quick answers from Jerry & The Mermaid staff and past visitors.