We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviewsbreakfast porchthird floorb bbrant pointwater streetin townyogurtoutdoor gardenquiet stayperfect visitwalking distance to the ferryrooms are beautifully appointedhomemade breadwater pressurejetties beachfelt like homewe've stayed
Accommodations were ok but the place could use some updating. Within walking distance from the dock. Continental style breakfast that included nutbreads, fresh butter and yogurt. Evidently Nantucket has restrictions on the type of food allowed to be served by B&B's.
Just got back from staying at The Carlisle Inn & we still love it! We've been to Nantucket many times & we always love staying at The Carlisle Inn whatever the season. The Inn is a perfect example of a preserved whale captains home -elegant...More
While the photos look really nice, we found the furnishings to be very tired, especially the bedding and furnishings in our room. We had an adjoining bath in this B&B in which you could not fit more than one person at a time. If you...More
Response from Carlislehouseinn, Owner at The Carlisle House InnResponded 18 September 2017
We constantly strive to provide an excellent experience for our guests, so we are dismayed by the comments made by this guest, particularly since she did not provide this feedback to us directly during her stay.
With regard to her remarks, we state clearly in...More
For 10 years, since she opened, I have been returning to Heather Sheldon's inn, The Carlisle House. I feel very comfortable in the Brant Point room on the lower floor. The inn's location is situated between town and Brant Point, so it's easy to be...More
Thank EDWARD L
Response from Carlislehouseinn, Owner at The Carlisle House InnResponded 11 September 2017
Thanks, Ed. It's always such a pleasure to see you! Looking forward to seeing you again soon.
We've been repeat guests for many years and continue to stay at the Carlisle, even now that we have a home on the island! Heather is a wonderful innkeeper. We stayed in Brant Point on the first floor, which is convenient for the breakfast porch...More
Response from Carlislehouseinn, Owner at The Carlisle House InnResponded 10 August 2017
It's always such a pleasure to see you! It has been wonderful getting to know you better and better each year. So glad you are now Nantucket homeowners who still stay at the inn when your house is rented!