We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviewsacross the streetbeach decorrental unitmontauk highwayshort walk to the beachheated poolclose to downtowngrounds are immaculatenice bathroomsink areafully equipped kitchennautical themeocean viewcolumbus day weekendpots and pansmorning coffeeditch plains
My wife and I wanted to visit Montauk (and the Hamptons) as we have never visited in our 35-40 years living in NYC. We lucked out with a very nice weekend in October as the rates were not peak.
The Beachcomber is located across the...More
You have to know Montauk to appreciate this property. Montauk is not cheap and overall none of the properties are overly luxurious. That being said, we really enjoyed our stay at the Beachcomber. Right across the street from the beach, we had an easy walk...More
First off, never ever stay on the first floor here!!! The ceilings are paper thin, so much so that when the person upstairs walks it sounds like an elephant stampede, and the ceiling fan shakes like a 7.0 earthquake. The walls are the same. If...More
We visited the Beachcomber in late September and found it to be a nice, quiet place. Our room was in the section closest to the road on the second level and the street noise never was a problem. The balcony faced the water and contained...More
Stayed on a Tuesday night in July. Our room was on the lowest level which sketched me out a bit when we sat outside and the cars going by seemed really close. The pool was heated and was empty on a Wednesday morning which was...More