We ate at several restaurants during our annual BI visit. Two excellent dinners at Winfields. Far better than any other restaurant on Island and even better than prior years. Also very good value for BI.
1 - 10 of 190 reviews
It had been about 10 years since we went to Winfield's, and now we see why many locals think it's the best restaurant on the Island. Erin, our delightful and knowledgeable server, filled us in on the menu items, including her favorites. We also were...More
This was our first time at Winfield's, but it won't be our last! Had a cozy table in the bar area, which we heard tends to be quieter than the main dinning room. Scallop appetizer was scrumptious, with a wonderful, light cream sauce and bits...More
Very nice setting, very attentive service and delicious menu. The menu is on the pricer side, however the quality seems top notch. Tried one of the specials which was a Lamb chop, was cooked perfectly and tasted wonderful. Great place for a romantic dinner or...More
Blackberry martini the best on the island! The meal was good but pricey. I ordered the brisket that was really fatty, so I couldn't eat about half of it. My friend ate the sirloin and it was fantastic with the au gratin jalapeño potatoes. They...More
Underwhelmed all around. Thought we'd go a little more upscale and indoors. Our portions were tiny and nothing was super special. The room was dark.
Maybe a bit variable, hence the 4 stars. We've been a dozen times over the last four years. Service is excellent, room "quaint" but not offensively so. Food mostly very good. I'd skip the garlic that comes w the bread to start, kind of too...More