We have been here a handful of times, with friends and family. Not one thing has ever been lass then wonderful. The chef is amazing, bar is perfect for a quick dinner also.
Is this a seafood restaurant?
Is this restaurant good for special occasions?
Does this restaurant have a TV?
Is this restaurant appropriate for Kids?
Does this restaurant offer takeout or food to go?
Does this restaurant serve alcohol?
Is this restaurant good for business meetings?
Is this restaurant good for large groups?
Is this restaurant good for lunch?
Is this restaurant romantic?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
I've been going to Jonathan's for over 10 years. Their trademark is consistency, both in the quality of their product as well as their service. No matter what you order, you'll probably enjoy it very much. Last night my wife and I had the Sunday price fixe special (28.95 per person). She ordered herb crusted salmon while I ordered chicken... More
We came in with over 20 people for brunch on short notice following our son's wedding. The staff could not have been warmer or more accommodating. The brunch selections were outstanding - so were the mimosas and bloody marys! We had a difficult time deciding what to order because everything sounded so amazing. Nothing ordered was disappointing. Loved that there... More
When we don't know where to go, when we want a general American menu, we fall into Jonathan's. The food is generally good, salads are nice, lamb chops are delicious and always tender, burgers are good. This time I took advantage of their lobster special. Never happened to me before but I ended up with a bad case of hives.... More
This restaurant is beautiful but it would s totally overpriced! The food is good but I wouldn't say exceptional not for the price! Their pork chops are good and the surroundings of the restaurant is beautiful but the prices belong in NYC not New Hyde Park, NY!
We were a party of 8 so I requested a table in the bar area, I thought it would be more intimate since the main dining room sounds like a school cafeteria, it is extremely loud and very crowded. What a mistake that was! The service was horrendous and the waiter was extremely rude. I should have known better, the... More
We went with a group of 14 people and they were so accommodating. They took a reservation on saturday night which was a huge problem I was having with area restaurants. The decor was very nice. It was sophisticated and elegant. The only thing I was not thrilled with was the prices were a tad high and the portion was... More
The staff is very accommodating and professional. We were a party of 8 and the orders were taken quickly and the food and drinks delivered professionally which is a welcome change to many restaurants today. Everyone was very pleased with their food, the lobster special which included a 1 1/2 lb lobster with salad, potato and corn for $32.95 is... More
easily accessible, ample on site parking. Accepted reservations and honored time of reservation. nicely decorated and staff were friendly and attentive. Very nice assortment of appetizers, entrees, and desserts. Have driven past this restaurant for years on Jericho Turnpike. but never thought to try the restaurant. Happily surprised and very pleased with my new find. Worth the visit.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing