Restaurant looked dark at lunchtime but turned out to be open. Quick service, two tasty pizzas and several sodas later everyone walked out happy.
1 - 10 of 116 reviews
Nice atmosphere. I liked the texture of the thin crust pizza. But disappointed in the clam pizza: no cheese, not flavor, and no garlic. Would have sent it back but our server (middle-aged male, in case manager is reading this) NEVER checked on us! No...More
We arrived 5 mins after five and saw that dinner starts at 5:30 so we left and decided to come back. We arrived 5:45 and the place was already packed! We know that it is a good place to eat then. We were seated after...More
Small and cozy, and at times a bit boisterous when big tables are filled, this unassuming place serves the best pie on the island if not all of New England. The crust, thin and delicious. The tomato sauce is fresh and fragrant especially when enhanced...More
Thank you for taking the time to write such a thoughtful and positive review of Pi Pizzeria. It's your warm thoughts and kind words that keeps us going strong through these very busy summer months.
It was a great meal and a great Pizza! Thin Crust--wood fired with crispy edges, just the way we like it! A ways out of town, but worth the walk!! Very Popular place that does not take reservations--get there early or plan on a wait....More
Thank you so much for finding us! Glad you enjoyed the pizza. We look forward to having you back again soon to try the other menu items
Restaurant does not take reservations When you call they say tables are available. When you arrive they tell you a twenty minute wait. There is no where to wait. After 45 minutes they say it will be another half hour!!! They should either take reservations...More
Thanks for reaching out to Pi Pizzeria and sharing your concerns. It is true that in July/August Pi Pizzeria on Nantucket is quite busy. Best practice would be to either arrive earlier or later as popular dinner times the wait is longer. You can enjoy...More
Got spaghetti and meatballs, and chicken piccata. Both average, but was more disappointed by something as simple to correct as they did not provide bread or rolls with the over priced spaghetti.More
I apologize that you were not happy with your dinning experience with us. We truly do try to provide excellent quality food for everyone all the time. Sorry you were not aware that we do offer warm bread, toasted garlic bread and toasted garlic bread...More
Great atmosphere and wish the pizza was better. Liked the thin crust but not real tasty. Will try again. Really like the interior. Very friendly staff.
Thanks so much for your recent visit to Pi Pizzeria. Please let us know how we can make your pizza better for you next time, on us! as we are happy to do it. Looking forward to you coming back and trying us again
Excellent menu all around. Fresh ingredients in every dish. The specials are always outstanding too! Oh yea and the BEST brick oven pizza on the plant for sure.
Hello Vincent, Thank you so much for your positive review! I'm glad that you notice and appreciate the top quality ingredients we use here at Pi Pizzeria. We look forward to seeing you again soon.