Mediocre. Note to self. Fish in a place called Tally Ho might not be the best choice. Had the fish been frozen only once, my grouper would have been satisfactory. But tasted like it had been frozen and thawed several times. Not good. But being...More

My wife and I spent a night in Selma on our way back to Florida. We wanted a good meal and decided on Tally Ho. We were not disappointed. I ordered the ribeye and my wife ordered the grouper special. The portions were large and...More

My wife and I got stranded in Selma, Alabama due to the Fla. storms, we made the best of it and found a great little restaurant, very hidden away in the suburbs. I had a great pork chop and my wife had the Chicken Parm....More

I phoned two weeks in advance and made a reservation for 12. We arrived and the reservation was not on the books. They eventually sat us, however, they seemed bothered by this and expressed it in front of us, the patrons. The food was only...More

We enjoyed a wonderful dinner at the Tally Ho in Selma. I ordered the fillet and it was cooked perfectly! Good atmosphere and courteous wait staff.

Stopped in for dinner during a cross country trip.road weary and underdressed,we snuck through the quaint dining room to the bar in the back.casual atmosphere,yet serving the same fare as the dining room.Morgan was our bartender/server.poured a nice drink and was spot on as a...More

Has appeal mainly because it seems to be the only restaurant in town, everything else seems to be fast food outlets on the main road. Tally Ho is hidden away in a suburban environment so you won't find it just driving by. It also seems...More

Spent two nights in Selma and this was the only restaurant we could find that wasn't fast food. It is in a residential neighborhood, which is kind of odd, but definitely worth a visit. The food was wonderful. Recommend the salmon and bacon wrapped filet,...More

Quaint atmosphere in a semi-fine dining restaurant. Great home style food that is a kind of cross between down home cooking and fine dining from a world class chef. I had the chicken parmesan, and I've never had better. You could actually taste the parmesan...More

Great place. Service was excellent. We visited on a Monday so it was very quiet. Steaks were great as was the Chicken Parm. Would highly recommend if you are in town.