Captain Tony's is a gem in Winslow. The service was fantastic, the help was flvery friendly, the pizza delicious, with many pizza and pasta options in the buffet, along with salad and cookies for desert. Make it your dinner stop in Winslow!
1 - 10 of 67 reviews
We stopped in for a Friday night pizza while on a road trip. The service was fast and friendly. If you like your pizza flavorful and loaded with toppings, go elsewhere. To its credit, the pizza was filling. Nice, family friendly atmosphere.
They were just opening when we arrived so the buffet wasn't ready yet. Ordered a salad and two medium hand tossed pizzas. The salad was ok, good dressing. The pizzas were both excellent. The service was friendly and efficient. We would go back if passing...More
Buffet style pizza joint. They have several different types of pizza plus salad and pasta. They pizza was pretty good, the salad was well salad. The pasta I would definitely pass on. The price was ok. They have beer so my husband was happy. They...More
We're not ones for pizza or salad bars, but we were happy to make the exception here. The service was friendly and excellent - even asking us if we would like a particular type of pizza added to the bar. We did and it was...More
I went there hoping to get a Calzone, but it was too large. It was basically a large pizza folded in half. I struggled to find something to eat, and the pizza on the buffet did not look fresh. So I decided to get a...More
We were traveling cross country and stopped for the night in Winslow Arizona. We were tired and hungry. The front desk person told us that only two places delivered, Pizza Hut and Captain Tony's, so we decided to give Captain Tony's a try. The delivered...More
We ordered a thin crust pepperoni pizza & cheesy breadsticks along w/ the salad bar & we were very pleasantly surprised! The pizza & breadsticks were DELISH! I saw reviews of the pizza bar pizza....the key is to order the pizza fresh. It is amazing...More