We had the lasagna dinner and chicken parm dinner with garlic knots... food was great, good size portions and each dish under 10 bucks... it was late so we did takeout back to our hotel. Very happy with meal, would recommend it!
1 - 10 of 18 reviews
More than happy. We were calling around for a pizza place and very happy we stumbled on Johnny's NY Pizza. Friendly staff. Answered my questions on the phone: yes they have a few booths to sit down and eat. Pizza crust was thin and crisp....More
High expectations based on other reviews resulted in...disappointment and frustration. I will say the pizza was fast and the service was friendly however the "Craig's Special" I got was soggy and the sauce was flavorless - you really couldn't detect any tomato flavor. Not only...More
This is our go to pizza place in my house....we're all from NY and this is the closest you will get to NY pizza outside of NY. The Mom's Favorite is a great idea to make everybody happy, half white, half red....delicious!
My husband (native New Yorker) only likes Johnny's. Everything we have had from combo, cheese, sausage and cheese pizzas have always been on our lists. The chicken parm is great according to my New Yorker. I love dipping my eggplant parm into the marinara The...More
We were welcomed as soon as we arrived, the pizza was ready and they thanked us for the order. The pizza was very good, a very god experience.
Real NY Pizza, big wedges, thin crust, nice toppings. Very good lunch special salad, drink, Stromboli for $7. Big salad that was fresh.
We recently moved to Lakewood and tried this place based on the reviews. I've never been to NYC so I can't say if its 'authentic' but I really like the pizza here. Its become my family's go to place for pizza. We've been going a...More