Lionshead must stop. Great seafood, service excellent (Will responsive, personable - especially hailing from Minnesota), patio seating. See and be seen.

Used to be our favorite but menu has changed and service was not up to previous experiences. Dined there twice last summer but only once this year.

This charming restaurant in Vail has recently opened for lunch as well as dinner, and it is definitely worth visiting. The fish of the day was trout with an amazing pineapple salsa, and the Icelandic cod fish and chips were the best we had ever...More

Has a great vibe ! Feels like you're at some old cool fish house on the coast of Long Island ( I lived in New England for a long time ... now in Dallas )...the food was delicious and the staff was so helpful... a...More

My family and I ate dinner here last weekend. Wonderful food, great waiter, fun atmosphere, very tasty cocktails and wine. I wish we had more time to have more meals here. Lobster rolls were like being back in Maine-Swordfish was excellent. Everyone was very happy...More

We had to go to this restaurant as we are from the East End of Long Island (near the real Montauk) It was such a surprise to us to get delicious fish in the Rockies!

Terrific seafood with outstanding, efficient and attentive service. Entrees are a bit on the pricey side, but then It's Vail (actually it's in Lionshead but for the tourist there's not much difference). My wife and I had a delightful dinner . . . she chose...More

Great place to eat. The crab legs were cooked perfectly. Definitely would eat there again. Nice atmosphere and great service staff.

King Crab was horrible. My wife and I split the crab and it was stringy inside and nothing left inside. Salad was fair. I wouldn't go back to this place on a bet.

A Vail Valley favorite since as long as I can remember, and I started coming to Vail in 1977, I chose Montauk for our 32nd anniversary celebration and we were not disappointed. I wasn't even expecting the 'off season' discount of 40% off the entire...More