My friend and I were in town and wanted to grab a quick bite for dinner, preferably a salad. We were near Mystic Pizza and decided to drop in. I feared we would have overpriced, underpass food....NOT AT ALL! Their menu is diverse with soup,...More

This place was fabulous! Did not expect to be blown away as I was... was expecting a little old pizza shop and was pleasantly surprised! The restaurant was fun and has a lot of charm and the food was delicious!! The service was fantastic -...More

My wife and I ate here on consecutive nights earlier this month. The first night we had a pizza which my wife said was the best she ever had. The second night, she said her hoagie was excellent. We enjoyed the memorabilia from the movie...More

This was our 1st trip to Mystic. Spur of the moment road trip on a cool April day. Walking around bopping in to a lot of shop we decided to try Mystic pizza for lunch. Great decision! We split a small Chicken - Gorgonzola -...More

Youre coming here for nostalgia. Downtown Mystic is so picturesque and Mystic pizza is the most famous place you can eat. The pizza is still pretty good – thick crust and generous portion sizes. Tons of memorabilia on the walls so its worth stopping by....More

Finally got a chance to check it out, the veg head pizza was delicious ! Great atmosphere just a good Ole pizza place

Everytime we go to Mystic we have to make a stop here. Best pizza. Spaghetti and meatballs pizza is my favorite!

The Pizza sauce is just so unique and tasty! We got the buffalo chicken - one of the best pizza's i've had

Went here for pizza because of the movie. Pizza was average (by New Jersey standards) and our kids loved the cheese garlic bread. Gina was our waitress and service was beyond excellent!!!

I was told by a finnicky friend that when she visited Mystic Pizza a few years ago that the pizza was just so-so. Well, she should go back again. This was my first visit to Mystic Pizza and I have to say it was definitely...More