We got the pepperoni pizza & were not disappointed. Usually I give my husband the crust, too hard or too dry. At Mystic it was the first thing I ate. The pan it's cooked in has bumps on the bottom. The cheese was darker &...More
1 - 10 of 1,722 reviews
Mystic is an idyllic little hide-away in south eastern Connecticut - and Mystic Pizza sits on the end of the street just down the hill from the beautiful old church. Made famous from the movie of the same name - Mystic Pizza does not disappoint....More
I first saw Mystic Pizza when it came out in 1988. Always wondered about this place and at 46 finally went. As a NYer there is NO PLACE BETTER THAN NY for pizza but Mystic did come in 2nd best. We ordered a small classic...More
Had a very tasty pizza and thoroughly enjoyed it. It's not a cheap pizza but worth the extra money. The place is charming, especially if eating in the dining room.
Went to Mystic Seaport is all day and hubby wanted pizza for supper so I said “wonder if there is a real Mystic Pizza place?” There is and it was so fun!!! Salad was fresh and delicious, pizza was really good, great crust. Service was...More
This is the pizza place that inspired the Julia Roberts film Mystic Pizza. Great shots of Julia and the other actors all around the resturant. This pizza is one of the best ever eaten. Don't miss if you are in Mystic.