This is the best frozen custard in key West. The owner is so friendly and very focused on high quality and customer service.
1 - 10 of 50 reviews
First of all lady behind counter was so nice and friendly! We are from England and had never had frozen custard before ( we only eat hot custard!) but we loved it! We had the key lime pie sundae which was out of this world!...More
It was lovely having you at the store. The key lime pie sundae is one of my favorites. I hope you all have been enjoying the rest of your time in Key West. Liz
We stopped by last night and I BROKE MY DIET!!! I loved it!! I might consider going back tonight hahahahaha
We are from St. Louis, which is home to Ted Drewes - the world's best frozen custard. My husband and I love ice cream and frozen custard and usually check out the local places whenever we travel. Boardwalk tasted more like ice milk. Not very...More
I'm sorry you did not like our product. It is lighter than frozen custard from the Midwest and is like the frozen custard on the New Jersey boardwalk.
I love frozen custard and we have some amazing places in Michigan. I was so excited to find a place on Duval. I ordered it and took a couple of licks and was disappointed. It was just not as rich of a custard taste that...More
I had a delicious chocolate custard ice cream with chocolate coat and jimmies. It was the highlight of the night 😃
Thanks for visiting us. I hope you enjoy the rest of your time in Key West.
My wife and I each had a cone here. They really weren't that good. My wife didn't even finish hers. The place was expensive. The cone I was given for my ice cream tasted stale.
I'm sorry you did not like our product. I hope the rest of your visit was better. Liz
Convenient and delicious! Have the chocolate and vanilla twist or the orange and vanilla twist! Located within 10 steps of hotel Casa 325!
Thanks for visiting us. Liz
This use to be a knor brothers and it is now boardwalk. Custard was good but it was better when it was knor brothers. It was creamier. but they do give a nice size serving and lots of sprinkles or jimmies depending were your from....More
Thanks for visiting us. The orange is a sherbet, which is part dairy (custard) and part non dairy, so it is not creamy like the custard. All of the other flavors (except key lime/lemon sorbet when we have it) are custard and are creamier than...More
We really enjoyed the frozen custard. Very creamy. We both had the vanilla and chocolate swirl. Will definitely stop there again on the next trip to the island.