I won't be going back bad service and dry steak with no flavor, I would not recommend this place. Plus it was pricey for what you get.
1 - 10 of 11 reviews
Absolutely the best steaks you are finding in this area. Every time you eat here you will believe that you have gone all out and chosen a spot that you would normally believe you would hold out for your 25th anniversary or some other special...More
This little steakhouse semi-hidden in the strip mall is a fabulous find. Small and intimate, romantic, fabulous food and all of the selections are fresh. Family owned and operated - steaks with a German flair. They are a bit pricey, but you get an excellent...More
Whenever we've dined at Matthew's, the service has been excellent and the food melted in our mouths. Perhaps because it brings back fond memories of Germany travels or because of the friendliness and warmth of the owners, the food tastes even better. My husband especially...More
Service was offstandish. Nothing special about the food. It was overpriced. In a strip mall near Publix grocery store. So for "high end" location is subpar.
For the past seven years I go to Windermere (Orlando suburb) to visit family. The first order of business is to put family in car and go straight to Matthews for a delicious meal. We stop for dinner there the next night too, and the...More
This is the best steak house in the area. American beefsteak is almost always a bit risky as far as flavor and texture. But I have experienced very good to excellent streaks here 9 out of 10 times. That's a great record. The seating is...More
I LOVED eating at Matthew's when I lived nearby. It is hands-down the best steakhouse. And I love steak and eat it often. They have a secret herbed butter you can spread on the steak, and that is amazing, too. They grill the steaks over...More
The only bad thing about Matthew's is the price...rump steak is a cheaper cut, but they charge like prime. That being said, it is the best tasting steak in town. period. The restaurant is both romantic and homey. Customer service is excellent and personal. My...More