Fantastic ice cream and gelato!!!! Generous portions!!! We visited 3x during our 7 day visit!! Take time to visit this place, you will not regret it. :)
1 - 10 of 1,868 reviews
The owner operated was very helpful on the description and taste of the items. Although we chose to take the items for later in the day, all items chosen exceed the items of deliciousness we chose. The operation features German and other choices and were...More
There's something about this place that just speaks to the old Sanibel, when it was less crowded and more casual and less touristed. It's like going back in time. Love sitting outside and eating my ice cream while watching the world go by. Good ice...More
Another chapter in our family ice cream challenge and nothing but a home run by Pinocchio's on Sanibel Island! I had the Italian Wedding and oh my was it tasty! Creamy and full of real almonds. This was delicious bliss to the taste buds! Nothing...More
Cute find, small space, great ice cream. Generous helpings and lots of toppings.... plenty of benches to eat outside but if there was a line, there is no where inside to wait.... it was 100% out so eating outside was murderous!! Could use a bit...More
Stopped in for Dessert. Great and unique flavors of ice cream and milkshakes. Good quality products.