Best homeade pies in town! Butterscotch is amazing and the others are as well! Coconut cream, black bottom, peanut butter - all so good!
1 - 10 of 53 reviews
Our group decided to meet up for pie after a day long event in the area. None of us are from the Lexington area so were not really sure what to expect. What we found was a quaint pies shop that emits the most wonderful...More
We got a gift certificate to try these pies, and we were not disappointed. All the slices we tried were very fresh. The combination pie was a definite winner!
Missy's is a small, easy to miss pie shop in downtown, but a great place to grab a slice of your favorite pie. Selections depend on what they are baking that day and what is on the shelf when you get there, but well worth...More
During our trip to Lexington, we were interested in the flavors of Kentucky, including a derby pie. This was my first experience with a derby pie, and it was was phenomenal! We also tried the peanut butter and key lime - all delicious! It's probably...More
I had pecan and my wife had key lime, while the key lime did not have whipped cream my wife said that it was good. The pecan pie was just what you would expect for a good pecan pie. You get a 1/4 of a...More
I had heard about Missy's from co-workers who had come to Lexington before me. I sought them out several times over the weeks I was in Lexington recently, including at Ramsey's which is a sister restaurant and serves the pies also. Good selection of types,...More
Recently our wine tasting group met and the theme was Low Country Fare. I was in charge of dessert and so I called Missy's and asked if they could fix a Praline Cheesecake. They indicated that they had never done that before but would give...More
I found this place by accident, looking for a cafe to have coffee and get out of the rain. I didn't know that I would be entering into this great pie bakery, which greets you like home, but smells and tastes much better than home....More