Not sure why this particular establishment gets all the accolades but founded very expensive. I've had better pies at the local supermarket

Landmark bakery in York closed down. Was the go to place for incredible pies. Hopefully a new bakery will take it's place.

Great pies for special occasions but the owners have recently retired . It's just a heads up for those who looked forward to eating or eating their pies .

Don't know if we were given an older pie, but the pastry was very soggy. I was glad that I didn't buy it to serve to guests. We ate it smothered in custard which made it taste better.

Yes, it's expensive but it was also the best crust, the best pie EVER! I'm a pie-snob and I loved it!!!

Beautiful , bursting with flavor berries, encased in a light, delicate crust. No gooey sugary syrup. Just mounds of glorious berries. It is expensive. And it is worth every penny!! This is to a grocery store pie, the equivalent of a fresh picked garden tomato...More

We stopped because my husband's family loved them from years ago. The baked goods look great, but if you bake yourself, don't buy there. It's expensive, way overpriced, and the pie crust looks terrific, but is heavy, and not flaky. If the attraction/price are the...More

Pie as a gastronomical art form! Everyone likes the blueberry but its the chocolate brownie style pie that is really incredible. We got two of them on a one week visit.

I took a nostalgic visit to Pie in the Sky. I had loved their baked goods years ago. OMG - $38 for a pie! It's a good pie, not a great pie. $3.50 for an awful and I mean awful blueberry muffin. I see that...More

Located on Route One I stopped for pie to take to a dinner party that we had been invited to. Although the pies were large, the prices totally shocked me. UNBELIEVABLE!!!! I left without a pie wondering if a pie could be that good to...More